Is there any mecha show worth watching? Until recently, my answer would have been “no.” None of the Gundams look the least bit interesting. I quit Evangelion after five episodes. I did make it all the way through RahXephon, though it gradually became clear that the creators had not thought their story through before they started. There are some shows with mechas that are worth watching, e.g. Nadesico, but in these the mechas are not central to the story. So, when I first read the synopsis of Bokurano, I figured it was something I could skip.
Bokurano got relatively little attention in the otakusphere during its run. I did notice, however, that the writers who followed it to its conclusion were ones whose opinions I take seriously, e.g., Owen and Concrete Badger, so I figured that perhaps I ought to check it out. I just watched the first four episodes, and, yes, it is something out of the ordinary.
Fifteen kids on a summer school field trip discover a cave filled with computers and other technology. There they meet a man who calls himself “Kokopelli.” He invites them to beta-test a new game, in which a giant robot they pilot defends the Earth from alien invaders. It sounds like fun, but they learn that the robot is for real, and so are the invaders. After demonstrating the robot’s use by fighting a giant mechanical insect, Kokopelli vanishes, saying “I’m sorry.” Perhaps it really is ultimately a game, but the damage wrought by the robot and invaders is immense, and there is a cost to piloting the robot. If someone dies during the game, there’s no resurrection.
The premise is rather dodgy — there had better be a damned good explanation before the series ends — but the characters are well-developed and distinctive. Each of the fifteen kids is different. Few of them represent any of the standard anime types. Some are good kids; others are jerks. I have no trouble keeping them all straight. Each of the kids has a family, and the families matter. The second and fourth episodes are more about fathers and sons than giant robots, and I expect that most of the remaining episodes will focus on exploring the character of each kid as he takes his turn directing the robot.
I probably will watch the rest of the series when I have time. Even if the show does turn out to be as good as the first four episodes promise, though, I hesitate to recommend it. It’s a cruel story in which anyone can die, and the main characters are all youngsters.
Bokurano really isn’t about the mecha, and rather is all about the kids and how they deal with the situations they find themselves thrust into. If you enjoy the first 4 eps, then you’ll almost certainly want to see this show through until the end. It’s certainly not an easy watch, but I found it to be very well done.
I don’t know if it’s really up your alley, but Gurren Lagann may be worth a look when the DVD’s start dropping in February. Gainax put a lot of effort into building the show around a spiral motif and as an homage to the various mecha generations that came before. So while the first few episodes seem a little odd and listless, after episode 6 you start to see things “spiral” up and out.
The really wonderful thing about it is that Gainax made sure they had somewhere to go in the last arc. They also managed their budget properly so we weren’t subjected to a repeat of Evangelion’s ending.
Just my two cents on something to look into.
I would say it lived up to the promise of the first few episodes. It’s a very unsettling show, though, and you’ve got the most unsettling parts ahead of you.
Though if you can keep all fifteen kids straight after only 4 episodes, that’s far more than I could say at that point in the show.
Eureka Seven is quite worth watching, if you can class that as a mecha show.