Dr. J. recently commented that “… there was no more deliciously evil character than Dolores Umbridge.” In the Potterverse, that’s unquestionably true. Umbridge is one of the best villains of recent years. But so is Kyubey. (And yes, Kyubey meets the Weatherwax criterion: he is indeed quite evil.)
So, how do you like your villains, delicious or cute? ((I’m aware that Kyubey is delicious, or at least edible. No wisecracks, please.))
Sorry, neither of them measures up to Cell.
I’d debate with you whether Kyubey is actually evil, Criterion or not, but I’m too darn tired.
He’s not evil, but it’s close enough for government work.
…and therein lies the rub.